• Paul Wagner 2018 - present
• ​Ken Stump 2016 - 2018
• Mark Woods 2003 - 2016
• Bill E. Williams 1991 - 2003
• Robert J. Kirk 1971 - 1990*
• Chester D. Putnam 1966 - 1970
• Arthur M. Roberts 1944 - 1965
• James H. Campbell 1935 - 1943
• A.F. Coonrod 1929 - 1934​
• H.C. Shellworth 1905 - 1948 as "Secretary Manager"

​*The combined position of Secretary Manager and Chief Fire Warden began under Robert J. Kirk in 1978 and has continued in this way ever since. The Association hires the Secretary Manager, and this person is then appointed as the State Fire Warden by the State Forester.

Paul Wagner, Warden 2018 - present

Bill E. Williams, Warden 1991 - 2003

H.C. Shellworth, Secretary Manager 1905 - 1948